Sherwin-Williams Paint: Emerald vs. ProMar — Understanding the Options and Why Prep Matters Most
- Aaron Furman
- Jun 30
- 2 min read
When homeowners choose paint, many lean toward Sherwin-Williams Emerald, believing it’s the “best” option on the shelf. At the same time, many contractors prefer Sherwin-Williams ProMar 200 for both interior and exterior work.
The reality? Both are excellent products — each suited to different needs and project approaches. The real difference comes down to application style, environment, and budget — not overall “better” or “worse.”
Emerald vs. ProMar: Different Strengths for Different Needs
Sherwin-Williams Emerald
Designed to provide strong coverage and a smooth finish.
Great for homeowners who want a balance of durability, washability, and a refined appearance.
Often chosen for feature spaces, accent walls, or areas where a little extra performance or finish detail is desired.
Sherwin-Williams ProMar 200
Reliable, versatile, and widely trusted by professionals.
Offers consistent performance and good durability, making it ideal for larger jobs or entire home repaints.
Easy to work with, touch up, and maintain — a major reason contractors reach for it.
In other words, both products can deliver a quality, professional finish when applied correctly. The choice depends more on project goals than on which one is “better.”
The Critical Factor: Prep Work
Whether you use Emerald or ProMar, neither will perform as intended without proper preparation. This is where many homeowners underestimate the importance of a good paint job.
What Proper Prep Includes
Cleaning and degreasing surfaces.
Repairing and patching cracks or holes.
Sanding for a smooth base.
Priming where needed for adhesion and uniformity.
Protecting floors, fixtures, and trim carefully.
A contractor who includes a dedicated line item for prep isn’t upselling you — they’re showing pride in their process. Prep work is often the difference between a paint job that lasts a couple of years and one that looks great for a decade.
Paying for Prep Saves You Money
Homeowners sometimes hesitate when they see prep costs broken out. But investing in prep reduces callbacks, touch-ups, and premature failure, saving you money and frustration over time.
The Bottom Line
Emerald and ProMar are both excellent choices when paired with thorough, professional prep. The real question shouldn’t be which paint to choose first — it should be: Who is doing the prep, and are they doing it right?
At Park County Construction, we believe in setting the foundation for a lasting, beautiful result — and that starts long before the first coat of paint goes on.